Episode 15, its finally happening

If you will, think about this way:

by not lynching anyone, the werewolves are free to kill again. So for evil to succeed is that good men do nothing....

By voting not to kill anyone, Amy accepts a stance ulterior than that of a neutral one.

Just putting this out.

? That actually makes no sense because werewolves want villagers dead and because they are working in a team they know who the other werewolves are and therefore they know who the villagers are. By killing off a villager during the day they essentially get two kills (one during the day and one during the night).

The reason I think we should vote no one is because we have a much higher chance of killing one of the villagers and therefore hindering ourselves.

....Arthur, can you explain the whole.."anyone but Michael" thing. That post was awfully suspicious.

I still stand by my vote of no one though.

Haha, on a side note this is seriously de ja vu from the last game of mafia.

why would I kill Aasav? I don't really have anything against him, and I would never want to kill anybody the first night anyways.

I also have a weird feeling it could be Arthur and Michael that are werewolves, trying to save each other from getting killed.

Well are we're going to get anywhere just waiting for the next person to be killed, eh?

Or are we simply going to stand around until the next villager dies, which may be you or I?


Oh Michael helped me out on a few things, it was just common courtesy in terms of lip service. Go ahead and vote for him if you wish.

I completely agree with you, at least about trying to "get anywhere", but we aren't really "getting anywhere" if we kill off an innocent villager and seriously hurt our chances of beating the werewolves.

Alright. Alright. Vote for whomever.

Votes so far:
No one: 1
Evan: 1
Failures: 1 (that's not a vote by any stretch of the imagination mr le

I vote for no one. But if I die next, its probably Arthur and Michael.

By the looks of it, most people are going to die due to inactivity.

Well, I'm voting Arthur

I vote Arthur as well.

Reasons:
1. Being butt buddies with Michael Le. Not only is it ridiculously suspicious in a game like werewolf, its also punishable by death in real life. Why not.
2. Random vote for Evan. In the beginning of the game, it is only the wolves who have nothing to lose by killing someone randomly. The point of accusing/voting on the first day isn't to try to get lucky, but to see how people defend themselves and identify suspicious patterns / reasoning. Choosing someone like Evan, who hasn't even posted so far clearly isn't going to give the villagers any new information. This just looks like a wolf looking for a free kill.

I could be persuaded to change my vote; I want to see Arthur's defense.

1. Better than going backwards and killing a villager without any evidence.
2. That excuse doesn't make any sense in the context of Arthur ruling him out as a suspect.
3. If Arthur was the seer or the fool his defense of Michael Le would be justified. The thing is, if we kill him and find out he's the fool, we'll know Le is a werewolf.

The possibility of us finding a werewolf, and suspicious behavior in general, prompts me to vote Arthur, pending differing evidence

1. Better than going backwards and killing a villager without any evidence.
2. That excuse doesn't make any sense in the context of Arthur ruling him out as a suspect.
3. If Arthur was the seer or the fool his defense of Michael Le would be justified. The thing is, if we kill him and find out he's the fool, we'll know Le is a werewolf.

The possibility of us finding a werewolf, and suspicious behavior in general, prompts me to vote Arthur, pending differing evidence

Just reverse that Brendan scenario, Banner, you better protect me. Unless I'm the Fool for the 3rd time... (If so I'm going to hurt you, James.)

Thus, I vote to kill Alan

Regardless if he's a wolf or villager, he just brings too much drama and mayhem to the game, hahaha.

Everyone's voting Arthur, but I don't think it's that simple.

Exactly. "ridiculously suspicious." If Arthur's a wolf I doubt he's stupid enough to protect his teammate in such a clumsy way. So my vote for now is no one.

I'd like to point out, regarding Michael and Brendan's post, that anyone else who has a power, other than the werewolves, has not gotten a turn yet (Mod check?).
Soo....if we look at Michael Le's post again...
"Just reverse that Brendan scenario, Banner, you better protect me. Unless I'm the Fool for the 3rd time... (If so I'm going to hurt you, James.)

Thus, I vote to kill Alan"

It seems to me that he's implying he used his fool/seer powers to find that it was Alan, but that's impossible because no one has used their power yet...

My werewolf predictions:
1. Michael Le
2. Arthur Halim

Michael for the above reasons...Arthur because Ferris's explanation makes sense. Plus, why hasn't he voted to kill anyone yet? I have a feeling he's waiting to see who gets the most votes and if he's close he can use his to sway it.

Since my first vote was simply to get things moving, I shall change my vote to suit what is currently required.

I vote Alan to defend myself.


And perhaps a side note, and differing evidence,
The premature collusion of lynching against me would better serve those purpose of the werewolves since they can easily eliminate a villager during the day and then kill someone else during the night. This strategy poised by those with allegations against me will most certainly point them out as the werewolves.

Ferris, Alan, and Brendan all responded consecutively which would lead me (and so should you) to believe that one or all have the high possibility of being werewolves.

Good job counting to three, but your defense is completely nonsensical. If you believed the premise on which your conclusion rests, you would be voting for nobody.

Updated vote:

No one: 3 (Amy, Raghav, Michael Ling)
Arthur: 3 (Alan, Ferris, Brendan)
Alan: 2 (Michael Le, Arthur)

(not bad, only 4/12 people have yet to vote)

What happens if the vote is tied?